What's yours? There are SO many to choose from: Time of the Preacher, Mr Bojangles, Rock'n'Roll I Gave You the Best Years of My Life, that Python Lee Jackson one ... number one in my personal chart (!) tho will always be Love's Been Good To Me by Rod McKuen, the best Canadian Buddhist and Brel translator ever to write hits for Frank Sinatra and Johnny Cash! ....


Views: 1428

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

By the way, Terry Jacks didn't write it and didn't have the British hit with it. It was Kevin Johnson and he really was a brilliant one hit wonder. This Terry Jacks version sucks, whereas Kevin's version made such a mark on my childhood that I can still sing it entirely to this day.
I stand humbled, corrected, educated and ashamed. Thanks! Much better, you're right of course
And for the record, my favourites are L.O.V.E which, by the way, Al Green also loved, so there Edwyn. (He cringes a little listening to it) and The Subway Sect's Holiday Hymn.
Second- third- and fourth-ed. L.O.V.E. introduced me to Al Green, and I've never known what people were talking about when they said Edwyn had no business flexing his own Muscle Shoals. EC hasn't done that much with his upper register since Hope and Despair, going in for octave-dropping crooning more often (correct if, as likely, wrong) but I find it as sweet in its way as my beloved Mariah. (In case anybody thinks I joke, cf http://www.guardian.co.uk/music/musicblog/2006/dec/11/whatswithallt...)

As for Vic, he is surely the most underacknowledged pop genius since pop history began. Despite the fact that he's had several major top 40 hits (by the remains of the 'Sect: http://www.joboxers.net/history.html. Vic's manager told me he wrote a lot of their songs, but if you look at the first JoBoxers' LP, there are NO songwriter details) and was a crucial contributor to Gorgeous George (if only for bringing EC and Paul Cook together, the world owes him a giga-Cheers!) the vast majority of people to whom you mention his name have no idea of whom you speak. The End of the Surrey People and The Long-Term Side Effect are two of my very favourite records ever, and there is significant overlap between the former unobtainable item and EC's absolutely justified global hit. (I always think in Girl Like You it's Vic I can hear whispering at the runout "Turn Left! Turn Left!")

This is a YouTube fave o'mine:

tho, off-topic, this baby - hang on, this grotty mobile fone concert footage has remarkably high sound quallity @£$%%(=** - I also love this. "You got us looking down at these keyboards now/It's never been the same since 1980 is one of the best couplets ever imho.

It is indeed Vic going turn left turn right and that was his idea....
But I am a Rod McKuen freak, so also love Love's Been Good To Me. Has he ever recorded that? I can't remember.
If he has, my shameless completism has yet to hunt it down!
Lindo, "We Come As Aliens", the new Sect LP is near completion. Release date due September. It is a masterpiece and will blow you away. Up the Hatters! Jim
I knew We Come As Aliens was brewing; hadn't realised it was due to be finished and released ahead of the songs from the musical Blackpool, that Vic wrote with Irvine Welsh, which I gather in fact is another couple of years off completion.

That's great. I shall go to bed dreaming of a support slot at the Edwyn QEH tickets for which I am the proud possessor
Just for the record - I think these are all covers Edwyn did:

L.O.V.E. Love Green / Mitchell / Hodges Can't Hide Your Love Forever
Holiday Hymn Vic Godard Ostrich Churchyard / Heather's On Fire
My Girl Has Gone Robinson / Moore / Tarplin / White Hellbent On Compromise
Time Of The Preacher Willie Nelson Hellbent On Compromise
After All (I Live My Life) Frankie Miller / Jimmy Doris Doctor Syntax (US Version)
The Witch Queen Of New Orleans P.Vegas / L.Vegas A Casual Introduction
Witchcraft Cy Coleman / Carolyn Leigh A Casual Introduction / Longapalooza
Ding A Dong Bakker / Mac / Luikinga A Song For Eurotrash
In A Broken Dream David Bentley If You Could Love Me (CD1)
Won't Turn Back Vic Godard Keep On Burning (CD1)
Mr. Bojangles Walker Adidas World (CD2)

Maybe I forget something ...
Damn. Never heard the Frankie "Gravel machine" Miller cover. Is it on plastic somewhere?
I'm sure you'll find the US version of Doctor Syntax at ebay. But - here it is. Not as good as In A Broken Dream. but with a hot guitar sound.



All things EDWYN and AED, NOW ON SALE:




and much, much more. . . 



  • 1.
    Lean Period
  • 2.
    A Sad Lament
  • 3.
  • 4.
    Low Expectations
  • 5.
    What Presence_!
  • 6.
    The Measure of the Man
  • 7.
    One Is a Lonely Number
  • 8.
    Campaign for Real Rock


  • Add Photos
  • View All


  • Add Videos
  • View All

Blog Posts

Art Work and Bum Fuzz

Posted by scott owen on May 5, 2017 at 17:15 0 Comments

My Bum Fuzz unit just arrived in California along with some plectrums with Edwin art. It took me along time to order this unit, but the twenty five year gestation period for it to be built surely eclipses my lack of urgency. Best regards all...

Thank you for the music

Posted by Carran Waterfield on August 2, 2016 at 13:56 0 Comments

A while back I asked Edwyn if he would let me use his music on a little film I made.  Here is the result: Mill Mechanics

Thanks for that.

Shareefa Energy Reasoning With Self - Review

Posted by ALAN HORNE on July 25, 2015 at 22:41 0 Comments

Shareefa Energy – ‘Reasoning With Self’ - Review

A few months ago the BBC offered a profile of new emerging female poets, ‘Women Who Spit’. Watching the short films by Jemima Foxtrot, Cecilia Knapp and Deanna Rodger, I noted with great relief that the art of poetry is alive and well. I have always been fascinated by the medium. The ability to express intricate thoughts and feelings in a few lines of words. It is the most empowering process. And empowerment through self-expression… Continue


Posted by steven brady on April 25, 2015 at 17:57 0 Comments

Dear Edwyn,

Can I just thank you for your contribution to my life. From that very first shiver I got listening to Felicity on the John Peel Show to the smile I still express today when you burst into laughter half way through Consolation Prize, it's important I let you know how much your music means to me before one of us croaks it.

I was hooked instantly and bought all the singles and albums, the ten inches, 12 inches and even ripped the flexi discs off Smash Hits and Melody…




Orange Juice Toppermost

Started by Andrew Shields in General Discussion. Last reply by Nestor Hernandez Mar 14. 12 Replies

Thought this might interest forum membershttp://www.toppermost.co.uk/orange-juice/Hot off the pressesContinue

Dad & Lad

Started by Kieron O'Callaghan in General Discussion. Last reply by Marie Mar 8. 1 Reply

Conversation last night with Ben(5)"Dad, can we watch rip it up on your phone again"?"Yes son if you want to""Is that Edwyn Collins Dad"?"Yes mate""I love this song Dad""I know you do Son""And Mr…Continue

Paul Quinn Toppermost

Started by Andrew Shields in General Discussion Dec 9, 2022. 0 Replies

Thought this might be of interest to forum members:https://www.toppermost.co.uk/paul-quinn/Continue

Punk Rock Hotel

Started by Frankie in Orange Juice / Postcard. Last reply by Andrew Shields Dec 8, 2022. 7 Replies

Does anyone know anything about this mythical film that Edwyn was working on in the mid 80's with Alan Horne and Paul Quinn? Paul Blue Eyes and Ain't That Always The Way were credited as being from…Continue

© 2023   Created by Administrator.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service